Steel vs Fiberglass Front Door: Which Is Right for Your Florida Home?

Your front door does more than welcome guests—it protects your home, affects your energy bills, and adds curb appeal. If you’re researching a steel vs fiberglass front door, you’re not alone. Many Florida homeowners compare the two materials when planning an entry door upgrade.

At Sunset View Windows & Doors, we specialize in high-performance fiberglass entry systems built for Florida’s coastal climate. While we don’t offer steel doors, we’ve included this comparison since many homeowners want to understand how fiberglass stacks up before making their choice.

The Main Difference Between Steel and Fiberglass Doors

Both outperform wood in strength, energy efficiency, and weather resistance. The key difference lies in the outer shell:

• Steel doors use a steel skin over a wood or composite frame—strong, secure, and budget-friendly. 
• Fiberglass doors feature molded fiberglass skins over an insulated foam core—durable, weather-resistant, and highly customizable. 

Both serve different needs. Here’s how they compare—plus where fiberglass stands out for Florida conditions.

Appearance and Style

Fiberglass: Customizable and Wood-Like

Fiberglass doors can be molded with authentic wood-grain textures that mimic oak, mahogany, or cherry. They come in a wide range of finishes, stains, and glass options, offering a traditional or upscale aesthetic without the maintenance of real wood.

Steel: Clean and Contemporary

Steel doors have a sleek, modern appearance, ideal for contemporary or minimalist homes. While they can be painted and even textured to resemble wood, their surface typically offers a smoother, more utilitarian look.

Verdict: Choose fiberglass for design flexibility and wood-like character. Choose steel for a bold, modern feel.

Durability and Maintenance

Fiberglass: Weather-Resistant and Long-Lasting

Fiberglass doors are ideal for Florida’s humidity and salt air. They won’t warp, crack, rust, or absorb moisture, and they hold their finish longer than steel in coastal conditions. Maintenance is simple; occasional cleaning with mild soap and water keeps them looking new.

Steel: Strong but Rust-Prone

Steel doors are extremely secure but can dent or rust if scratched or neglected. They’re durable under impact but require more upkeep—scratches must be repainted promptly to prevent corrosion.

Verdict: For low-maintenance durability, fiberglass is the better choice in Florida’s climate.

Energy Efficiency

Both door types include insulated cores that outperform wood. However, fiberglass generally provides better thermal resistance.

• Fiberglass doors prevent heat transfer, keeping interiors cooler during Florida summers. 
• Steel doors can absorb heat, especially when painted dark colors, making them hotter to the touch and slightly less efficient. 

Verdict: Fiberglass wins for energy efficiency and comfort.

Security

Steel doors lead in pure strength—they’re harder to force open, making them ideal when security is your top priority.

Fiberglass doors, while also strong, have a bit more flexibility and may not withstand heavy impacts as well as steel.

Still, real-world home security depends just as much on installation quality and locking hardware as door material.

Verdict: Steel is strongest overall, but both provide excellent security when installed professionally.

Cost Comparison

• Steel doors: Typically $500–$1,000 installed, making them one of the most affordable exterior door options. 
• Fiberglass doors: Range from $1,200–$3,500 installed, depending on style, finish, and glass inserts. 

While fiberglass costs more upfront, it offers longer lifespan, better insulation, and lower maintenance costs over time.

Steel doors deliver strong value and security for homeowners on a tighter budget.

Verdict: Steel wins on price; fiberglass wins on long-term savings.

Lifespan and Warranty

• Fiberglass doors can last 25–50 years with minimal maintenance.
• Steel doors last around 20–30 years with proper care. 

Most fiberglass models, like those from Therma-Tru®, include extended or lifetime warranties, while steel warranties typically range between 10–20 years.

Verdict: Fiberglass offers a longer life and stronger warranty coverage.

Which Is Better for Florida Homes?

For coastal Florida conditions, fiberglass doors outperform steel in several key areas:

• Resist rust and corrosion from salt air
• Offer better insulation and energy savings
• Require minimal upkeep
• Maintain their finish and color longer 

Steel doors are best if:

• Security and affordability are your priorities
• You prefer a modern, minimalist design
• You’re upgrading a rental or secondary property where budget efficiency matters 

Bottom line:

• Choose fiberglass for superior longevity and appearance.
• Choose steel for high security and affordability. 

Why Sunset View Only Installs Fiberglass Entry Doors

We choose fiberglass because it consistently delivers the best results for Florida homeowners and meets our installation standards for long-term performance.

At Sunset View Windows & Doors, you get:

• Veteran-owned, second-generation expertise
• Licensed Florida contractor (#SCC131152651)
• In-house installers (no subcontractors)
• Premium brands like Therma-Tru®
• A true 10-year workmanship warranty
• Impact-rated options that meet Florida Building Code standards 

Our customers trust fiberglass because it provides strength, beauty, and reliability—without the climate-related issues steel can bring.

Quick Comparison: Steel vs Fiberglass Front Doors

Ready to Upgrade Your Front Door?

If you're deciding between steel and fiberglass, our team can walk you through what works best for your home—and why fiberglass is typically the smartest choice for Florida’s climate.

📞 Call (321) 242-2244 or schedule your free estimate online today.
Protect your home, enhance your curb appeal, and see why your neighbors trust Sunset View Windows & Doors for quality that lasts.